How farmers adopt new products and practices?

1. The Farmer Decision Environment

Farmers are hybrid decision-makers operating in a complex system.

Their decisions balance:

Commercial logic: return on investment, productivity improvements, risk reduction, and compliance.

Lifestyle motivations: affinity to land, independence, time pressure, family environment, and ease.

Farm system constraints: existing infrastructure, seasonal workloads, labour availability, and supplier relationships.

If an innovation conflicts with the system, adoption slows.

2. The Adoption Equation

Farmers adopt innovations when this equation works:

Perceived Benefit > Behavioural Friction + Risk/Uncertainty

Benefits: productivity gain, cost reduction, lifestyle improvement, and reduced labour.

Behavioural Friction: changes to routines, learning curves, new management complexity, and system disruptions

Risk / Uncertainty: reliability concerns, lack of proof, supplier trust, and trade-offs.

3. The Proof Gap

Most agricultural innovations follow a pattern:

Early adopters try → market pauses → proof accumulates → broader adoption

Companies often misinterpret the pause as failure.

In reality, the market is waiting for local proof, trusted farmers adopting, and repeatable results across seasons.

4. Trust Networks

Word of mouth is the most powerful form of marketing in agriculture, which means adoption can be heavily influenced by:

  • respected farmers

  • farm advisors

  • vets

  • trusted reps

  • rural retailers

These networks often matter more than product claims.

Implication
Due to the multi-factorial nature of on-farm decision-making, marketing to farmers is hard. Success in selling to farmers results from getting a range of things right. It is not just down to having a successful marketing campaign, or securing distribution, or having a good sales team.

It is about understanding a farmer’s priority stack, where you sit in it, and what the most effective levers are to pull that will move you up it.

Scenic view of green outdoors with tall grass in foreground, trees, rolling hills, and mountain range in the background under a partly cloudy sky.

The Two Types of Innovation

Plug-in innovations

Examples:

  • new drench

  • new fertiliser

  • improved genetics

Biggest adoption barrier = confidence and proof

System-changing innovations

Examples:

  • shed automation

  • digital farm systems

  • new grazing technologies

Biggest adoption barrier = behaviour change

Having a thorough understanding of the adoption barriers is key to successful market uptake.

Pro tip: they are not always what the farmers say they are. Farmers will often tell you what you want to hear, not what you need to hear (to preserve a relationship, or they don’t have time, or they simply cannot be bothered)